One-time password (OTP)
OTP stands for One-Time Password which is a unique password that is valid for only one login session or transaction. Also known as a dynamic password it’s a powerful tool in the fight against cybercrime providing an extra layer of security to protect sensitive data and systems from unauthorized access.
OTP’s are designed to counteract the risks of fixed (static) passwords. The main advantage of an OTP is that it reduces the risk of a hacker intercepting the reusable password. As the name suggests an OTP is not vulnerable to replay attacks because it’s not valid for more than one login session or transaction.
What is a One-time Password?
A one-time password (OTP) is a unique, auto generated code that is valid for only one login session or transaction. Unlike static passwords which remain the same until changed by the user, OTP’s are designed to be used once. This makes them a form of strong authentication providing an extra layer of security to protect sensitive data and prevent unauthorized access.
OTPs are often used in conjunction with static passwords to provide two-factor authentication. This means to gain access a user must provide something they know (their static password) and something they have (the OTP). Even if an attacker gets the user’s static password they would still need the OTP to complete the login session. This makes OTP’s a good tool to protect sensitive data and ensure secure access to systems.
How OTP works with an authentication server
One-Time Passwords are generated using algorithms that produce a unique set of credentials for each login attempt. These algorithms can be time-based, counter-based or a combination of both. The generated OTP is then sent to the user via a secure channel such as SMS, email or a dedicated authentication app.
The authentication server works with OTP generators to validate login attempts on unauthenticated devices, providing extra security and robust identity verification in various digital transactions. The user enters the OTP in the login interface and the system verifies the password. If the OTP matches the one generated by the system, the user is granted access. If not the login attempt is rejected. The OTP is then discarded and cannot be used again even if it’s intercepted during transmission.
Time-based OTPs
Time-based OTPs (TOTPs) are generated by applying a cryptographic algorithm to the current time. The algorithm uses the time as a seed to generate a unique password. The time is usually divided into intervals of 30 or 60 seconds and a new OTP is generated for each interval.
The advantage of TOTPs is that they don’t require a network connection to generate or validate the OTP. However the device generating the OTP and the server validating it must have synchronized clocks. If the clocks are not synchronized the OTPs generated will not match the ones expected by the server and the login attempts will fail.
Counter-based OTPs
Counter-based OTPs (HOTPs) are generated by applying a cryptographic algorithm to a counter value. The counter is incremented each time an OTP is generated. The server keeps track of the counter and expects the next OTP to be based on the next counter value.
The advantage of HOTPs is that they don’t require clock synchronization. However they do require the server and the device generating the OTP to have consistent counter values. If the counters get out of sync the OTPs generated will not match the ones expected by the server and the login attempts will fail.
OTP delivery methods for 2 factor authentication
Once an OTP is generated it must be delivered to the user in a secure manner. One-time password examples include OTP security tokens which are devices or applications used to generate a temporary code for secure access. There are several ways to deliver OTPs each with its own pros and cons.
Common delivery methods are SMS text messages, emails, dedicated authentication apps and hardware tokens. The choice of delivery method depends on the system requirements and user’s preference.
SMS and email
SMS and email are the most common delivery methods for OTPs. They are convenient for the user as they don’t require any additional hardware or software. However they are also the most vulnerable to interception. If an attacker can get access to the user’s email account or intercept their SMS messages they can steal the OTP and gain unauthorized access to the system. Also reusing the same password across multiple accounts can further increase security risks as it makes it easier for attackers to breach multiple systems once they have access to one password.
Despite these risks SMS and email are still widely used because of the convenience. To mitigate the risks additional security measures are often implemented like encryption of the OTP and use of secure email protocols.
Authentication apps and hardware tokens
Authentication apps and hardware tokens are more secure delivery methods for OTPs. They generate the OTP on the user’s device so the risk of interception during transmission is eliminated. However single factor authentication (SFA) which relies mainly on username and password for user access has huge vulnerabilities. High profile incidents like the Colonial Pipeline attack have shown that compromised passwords can lead to major security breaches and that’s why we need more robust security measures like multifactor authentication. However they require the user to have a compatible device and to install and maintain the app or token.
Authentication apps like Google Authenticator and Authy generate OTPs using TOTP or HOTP algorithms. The OTP is displayed on the device’s screen and entered by the user during login. Hardware tokens work in a similar way but the OTP is generated by a dedicated device usually in the form of a key fob or card.
One-time Password Security
One-time passwords are designed to be secure and resistant to various types of attacks. They are usually generated using a pseudorandom number generator (PRNG) or a cryptographically secure pseudorandom number generator (CSPRNG). These generators produce unique and unpredictable codes so it’s extremely hard for attackers to guess or replicate the OTP.
To add more security OTPs are usually time limited meaning they can only be used within a short period usually a few seconds or minutes. This time constraint ensures that even if an OTP is intercepted it becomes useless after the validity period expires. OTPs can be delivered to users through various channels like SMS, email or dedicated apps on the endpoint. Each delivery method has its own security considerations but the time limited nature of OTPs helps to mitigate the risk of unauthorized access.
Use Cases for One-time Passwords
One-time passwords have many use cases so it’s a versatile tool for security across various domains. Some common use cases are:
-
Secure access to online banking and financial services: OTPs are used to authenticate users during online banking transactions so only authorized individuals can access sensitive financial information.
-
Authentication for e-commerce transactions: Many e-commerce sites use OTPs to verify the user’s identity before processing payments.
-
User identity verification for sensitive data access: Organizations use OTPs to control access to sensitive data so only verified users can view or modify critical information.
-
Secure login for corporate networks and systems: OTPs are used to protect corporate networks and systems from unauthorized access especially in remote work setup.
-
Two-factor authentication for online services and apps: OTPs is a part of two-factor authentication for various online services and apps.
-
Password reset and recovery: OTPs are used in password reset and recovery process so only the legitimate user can reset his password.
By serving these many use cases one-time passwords is a big help in security and protection of sensitive data across different industries.
Compared to Static Passwords
One-time passwords has many advantages over static passwords. Static passwords are vulnerable to many attacks like phishing, password cracking and password reuse. These vulnerabilities are because static passwords remains the same until the user decides to change it making it an easy target for attackers.
On the other hand OTPs are unique and unpredictable so it’s much harder to be attacked. Each OTP is valid for one login session or transaction and it’s usually time limited so the risk of unauthorized access is reduced. The dynamic nature of OTPs ensures that even if an attacker intercepts the OTP it cannot be reused.
Moreover OTPs can be used to provide two-factor authentication adding an extra layer of security to the authentication process. So even if an attacker gets the user’s static password he still needs the OTP to access. This dual requirement makes OTPs a more robust alternative to static passwords.
In summary static passwords are vulnerable to many security threats one-time passwords is a more secure and reliable way of authentication and protection of sensitive data and systems.
Advantages and disadvantages of OTPs
OTPs has many advantages over static passwords. It’s resistant to replay attacks since it’s only valid for one login session or transaction. OTPs adds protection to a user’s identity during authentication process so even if login credentials are compromised it’s still protected from unauthorized access. It also adds an extra layer of security since even if the user’s primary password is compromised an attacker still needs the OTP to access.
But OTPs also has some disadvantages. It requires more effort from the user since he needs to receive and enter the OTP during each login. It also requires additional infrastructure to generate and deliver the OTPs. If the OTP is lost or intercepted the user will be locked out of the system until a new OTP can be generated and delivered.
Advantages
One of the main advantage of OTPs is it’s resistance to replay attacks. Since each OTP is valid for one login session or transaction even if an attacker intercepts the OTP he cannot use it to access the system unauthorized.
OTPs also adds an extra layer of security. Even if the user’s primary password is compromised an attacker still needs the OTP to access. So OTPs is a good tool for protecting sensitive data and systems.
Disadvantages
One of the main disadvantage of OTPs is the extra effort from the user. The user needs to receive and enter the OTP during each login which can be inconvenient especially if the user logs in frequently.
OTPs also requires additional infrastructure to generate and deliver the OTPs. This can add complexity and cost to the system. If the OTP is lost or intercepted the user will be locked out of the system until a new OTP can be generated and delivered.
Summary of OTPs
In summary OTPs is a powerful weapon against cybercrime. It adds an extra layer of security to protect sensitive data and systems from unauthorized access. Although it has some disadvantages it’s a must have in any robust cybersecurity plan.
As cyber threats evolves the importance of OTPs will only increase. By knowing how OTPs work and how to use it you can boost your system and data security.
This post has been updated on 19-11-2024 by Sofie Meyer.
About the author
Sofie Meyer is a copywriter and phishing aficionado here at Moxso. She has a master´s degree in Danish and a great interest in cybercrime, which resulted in a master thesis project on phishing.